5 Frighteningly Sexy Horror Movie Villains

By Loryn Stone


My literary hero, the dark lord and master himself, R.L. Stine once said that humor and fear are very closely tied. We get scared, yet once we realize everything is okay, we laugh. It’s a sweet and innocent anecdote that perfectly sums up the childhood experience of being scared by a harmless, and welcomed boo.

But what happens when we get older?

Well, for many of us, nothing. We either read or watch scary stories, revel in the rush of adrenaline brought on by the fear, the heightened senses, the wondering who could be nearby…watching us. But, if you’re a pervert like me (and I’m sure many, many of you are), you look at scary stories and horror movies and you’re gazing at the antagonist with sexual intrigue. After all, they’re nothing more than bad boys in disguise, right?

Don’t answer that.

That’s why today, we’re counting down 5 Frighteningly Sexy Horror Movie Villains!

5. Pennywise the Clown from IT

Before we start with the actual character Pennywise the Dancing Clown, let’s start off with the two actors who have tackled the role of the unpredictable clown. First Tim Curry in the original 1990 mini-series, and then Bill Skarsgard in the 2017 remake. And what do these two actors have in common?

That’s right- they’re both absolutely gorgeous.

Albeit, different flavors of the sexy, but beautiful either way. This is very important. Yes, sure, Pennywise might be some sort of alien-demon-monster-creature, but it leads you to wonder…hey…what’s under all that blood and makeup and sharp-ass teeth?

Pennywise 5.JPG
He’s probably a really nice guy.

The character himself has swagger. His presence is powerful, someone you crave to come back after he’s left the scene. He looms over the children, feeds off their fear, and hates them for merely existing. How fucking cool is that?

Pennywise 2

He’s such an automatic bad-boy that it makes you wonder if you can turn him…or maybe…

Turn him on?

“My balloon’s not the only thing that floats…”

It’s intriguing too, that the character’s favorite form is the clown. And why shouldn’t it be? Those glowing yellow eyes, that knowing smile…really, if those kids were just a little older, say 16-20 we would have a very different narrative. Hell, reports state that he was even supposed to shift into Freddy Kruger at one point in the script. It’s a good thing he didn’t, because not only would that be a silly choice that pulls you out of the narrative, but you’ll see evidence in our next entry that it would have been sensory overload. Instant orgasms on the spot from all female, queer, and smart audience members.

Especially since Beverly isn’t afraid of the clown as-is (you know, since she has that whole molesty-dad problem at home…which really, is way scarier than some sexy-boogeyman).


And because the clown’s sexiness isn’t overtly sexy, but accidentally sexy, there’s a good chance that it represents that delicate divide between childhood ending and adolescence/adulthood beginning. In fact, I recall reading interviews with Stephen King that claim that his sewer-gang-bang scene was supposed to be beautifully symbolic and represent the ending of childhood and the blossoming of adulthood.

But really, I think drinking too much tequila, making out with your best friend’s sibling, and passing out upside down in the front yard accomplishes the same thing.

And truthfully, it’s a billion times less creepy. A billion times.

That’s a legitimate statistic, big dawg.


4. Freddy Krueger from A Nightmare on Elm Street

Freddy 1.png

Those of you who’ve been goodly enough to follow my writing for a minute know I’m a huge fan of Freddy Krueger. I love the character. I love his movies. Last year, Cracked was kind enough to let me write a love letter to the franchise, and I did so by comparing it to the life-cycle. Essentially, I theorized that each movie, all nine of them featuring our favorite nightmare-murdering-sandman represented a different point in life from puberty to death.

The long and short: Freddy Krueger is a charismatic sex god.

Freddy 2.jpg

I’m going to let images speak for themselves. Look at the way Freddy gazes at the camera. Look at the way his female co-stars pose with him, like he’s a member of Twisted Sister or whatever the fuck band was hot at the time.

Freddy 5.jpg

Look at the way his face is position between those two blades. What is he suggesting here? That’s right- razor sharp at it may be, he’s ready to slather the cunny in some tongue flicking goodness.

Freddy 4

As if the pictures weren’t enough, we all know Freddy is ready to spout some innuendo at any given moment. Remember in the original A Nightmare on Elm Street after he and Nancy have their little phone call? He says “I’m your boyfriend now, Nancy.” And his tongue slips right into the phone. In the same film, when Nancy is taking her bath, we see his gloved hand poke through the water’s surface and between Nancy’s legs.

In A Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master, Freddy helps himself by crawling into bed, right on top of the protagonist, Alice. Hell, in the 5th movie The Dream Child, the whole point is Alice is pregnant with his demon spawn (all right fine, he just enters the mind of the sleeping, gestating baby, but come on. Semantics.)

Last but not least, and one of my favorite Freddy moments, he tells Lori (the virgin protagonist of Freddy Vs. Jason) I should warn you, princess… the first time tends to get a little…messy.”

See that? She’s swooning.

Sure, all right, in context it might all be because Freddy was originally slated to be a child molester. However, that was removed from the source material, opting for a child killer instead. They mention in Freddy Vs. Jason that he especially likes little girls. But from what I can see in the films, Freddy’s ready to take it to the bone-zone with some hot, glorious barely-legal-ladies.

…we’re not building the best case here, are we?…

Moving on!

3. Eric from The Phantom of the Opera


I’ll tell you guys something really funny about being paid to write. So, when you’re paid to write a thing you successfully pitch, it’s imperative that you’re flexible. You might need to adapt your ideas to suit the narrative set in place by the publication’s agenda or vibe. And that’s okay! Ideas are cheap- write the thing that needs to be written.

That said, when I wrote this thing for Cracked about female fantasy movies falling apart with a single change, I (voluntarily) took the angle that The Phantom of the Opera wouldn’t work in real life because Christine isn’t an idiot. Any smart, young woman would recognize the signs of dangers and never give in to The Angel of Music’s pull, his dark sensuality, his obsessive romance for the young opera singer.

Well, that was all a load of crap.

The Phantom of the Opera is one of the sexiest horror movie villains that’s ever existed. Hands. Fucking. DOWN. I’ve seen every on-screen version (though the book was work to get through, I tried my best). From Lon Chaney, to Claude Rains, to Michael Crawford, Robert Englund (playing Freddy the Phantom), to Gerard Butler, Ramin Karimloo, and even know that KISS’ Paul Stanley played him once and Jeff “The Mannequinn” Hyslop from Today’s Special all took a crack at the phantom. I love The Phantom of the Opera.

And Eric, the phantom, is HOT.

Phantom 11.jpg

He comes out of your mirror and he’s in love with you! For fuck’s sake, he’s been watching you. How much has he seen? Not knowing is kind of cool. I mean, you don’t even have to do anything and the romance and magic just comes to you! Isn’t that everyone’s dream?

Sure, okay, he’s a psycho killer and murders stage hands and shit. But like, he keeps you intact. He only threatened to slap Christine once, and it’s because she pulled his mask off. Doesn’t he know he was wearing that thing for a reason? If he wanted her to see his face, he would have pulled the mask off when they dropped down once more into the filthy sewer. Right?

And when that moment finally comes, after that passion pumped song “Point of No Return/Down Once More” when Eric and Christine kiss AT LAST?! What happens then? Exactly: he decides that shit wasn’t so much worth waiting for and he sends her home.

Just kidding, his heart is broken, he loses his only love, and hem escapes the opera house. Because drama.

2. Candyman from Candyman

 Candyman 1.jpg

I’ve only seen Candyman once, but holy shit, it made an impact. As if the urban setting wasn’t creepy enough, and the whole spin on the good old Bloody Mary story wasn’t Creepsville (say CANDYMAN FIVE TIMES IN THE MIRROR) the movie sure made a whole generation of us afraid of public park restrooms and fucking bees. This movie nailed the scary bees thing long before Nick Cage made that meme of a remake they call The Wicker Man.

Candyman 2.png

But holy mother, the actual Candyman himself was gorgeous. The first time he made an appearance in his trench coat and hook, I was in love. What a sexy man. And some serious bedroom eyes to boot. It almost forgave that whole “slashing people and murdering angle”.

Candyman 5

One thing I do love about Candyman is toward the end it pulls a fast one on you. It changes the narrative from “crazy urban legend plantation slave’s son creature-man” to a romantic Destined Couple story about a woman who falls in too deep and discovers she is the reincarnation of the murderer’s lost love. It’s beautiful and tragic and it fleshes out the narrative to more than a cosplay-worthy-beautiful-bee-man wrecking faces with his bad-ass hook.

Candyman 6.jpg

Le sigh…devotion is a beautiful thing.

1. Lestat from Interview with the Vampire

Lestat 4.jpg

The funniest thing about Tom Cruise’s original depiction of Lestat from Interview was the amount of praise he got for his acting. But as time went on, I came to realize this is the least amount of acting he’s ever done. Much like Lestat, Tom Cruise is completely insane. It’s like someone stuck him in front of a set, pointed at Brad Pitt looking his hottest, and said “Hey, just go talk to that dude, okay?”

Lestat 3.jpg
“I’m telling you, these craft services are to die for…”

Personally, I’ve never seen the 2001 sequel (or whenever the hell it was made, it’s not really worth looking up) Queen of the Damned starring Aliyah with her mouth open on the poster.

Lestat 1

But from the screen shots and gifs I’ve seen, I’m boggled by how much Stuart Townsend looks like the vampire boy from Twilight.

Lestat 6

To the point that when they were casting Twilight, the producers said “Hey, people like that Lestat guy, why don’t we get a guy who looks like him to be Edward? No, not Tom Cruise, the newer one. The one who rolls his eyes and sighs. Yeah, like Lestat mixed with some Hayden Christiansen. Oh, Robert Pattinson? Perfect, nailed it.”

Lestat 2.jpg

I remember watching Interview back in 1994 and being totally into it. While my mom and sisters were going gaga for Brad Pitt, I remember being transfixed by Lestat’s body language. There was a cool arrogance about him, his carefree laughing at people’s anger that resonated with me. And of course, when it came down to it, he was a murderer. And in spite of giving Louis “The choice he never had”, Lestat seemed pretty down on that vampire life. And collecting hot dudes life. And trapping them with a baby life. Hmmm…on second thought, dude had some gnarly issues. Maybe we should recast our #1 spot. Perhaps so. Sexy, sexy…horror movie villain who is sexy….


How about that Beetlejuice guy?

Yeah…I’d totally hit that.


Loryn is Pennywise trash. To summon her on Twitter, just say her name 5 times.

If you like what you see here, you can follow PopLurker on Twitter and Facebook!

Support us on Patreon and we can make more hilarious content!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s